Work, Productivity & Pay
  • Home
  • Browse
  • About
  • Conversations
Work, Productivity and Pay

Wanjiru Njoya, PhD (Cantab.) MA (Oxon.) LLM (Hull) LLB (Nairobi) PCAP (Exeter)
​Fellow of the UK Higher Education Academy

​​​

Cecil Rhodes

13/10/2021

1 Comment

 
​My name is Wanjiru and I am proud to have been a Rhodes Scholar. Kenya and St Edmund's College Cambridge, 1998, since you ask.
​
If I had met Cecil Rhodes the first thing I would have said to him is 'thank you for funding my education'. I'm very polite that way. I was raised to have good manners, always to say please and thank you. So, thank you Mr Rhodes!

​With the pleasantries out of the way, we could go on to compare our adventures. He could tell me how he appropriated a chunk of Africa and gave it his name, and I could recount how I appropriated a little corner of England where I love to sit in the garden among the late-blooming pink roses and read books. Seems fair to me, that if an African woman can make her home in England then an English man can make his home in Africa.

Next up would be the matter of his imperialism. It is fashionable nowadays to pretend to be very interested in the true historical facts about the misdeeds of imperialists. Like a Newsnight Inquisitor: "Tell me Mr Rhodes, just how evil a man would you say you were? How sorry and ashamed are you now for what you did?" We want to know the facts about how evil they were, all the rude things they said about other races, so we can shake down their heirs for some compensation, maybe a bit of power-sharing, maybe even some expropriation to equalise things and correct historical wrongs. But historical wrongs do not justify new wrongs.

It is true that those colonies were not taken with smooth talk, and one can think only with shudders and anger of the fearful mass murders that prepared the basis for many of the colonial settlements flourishing today. But all other pages of world history were also written in blood, and nothing is more stupid than efforts to justify today’s imperialism, with all of its brutalities, by reference to atrocities of generations long since gone.

Ludwig von Mises, Nation, State and Economy (1919)
​

This does not mean being so happy with the status quo that we consider imperialism to be 'worth it' for all the great legacies it yielded.

[Mises] is not saying, “Yes, there were horrible massacres under imperialism, but these were justified to open the world to trade, because, after all, ‘the pages of world history are written in blood.’” He is saying that people after World War I who favor imperialism should not use the excuse that the pages of history were written in blood to justify wars of expansion.

David Gordon, The Anti-Imperialist Ludwig von Mises
​
Nor, we might add, should we use the old wounds to justify ​new forms of evil, as pay-back for the old forms of evil. 

The real aim of historical fact-finding and plaque-shaming imperialists is to gather ammunition with which now to take aim at the British in order to support the case for Socialism and Reparations and new forms of Equity that are nothing more than a mask for vengeance and retribution.  The plaque-shaming 'retain and explain' missions are selective. They're digging for dirt to throw at historical monuments. They are not interested in highlighting all the relevant facts.

Cecil Rhodes was an imperialist, as were many around the world at the time, including Africans, notably Menelik II of Abyssinia; but he is of note in Oriel and Oxford as a whole as a benefactor of great generosity and imagination.
​
Jeremy Black, 'Retain and explain' was a compromise too far
​

If you already know the truth about socialism (it doesn't work), and have formed your own view about those begging for their reparations (shameful), there is no need to feign an interest in this historical fact-checking charade. So we can skip pretending to debate whether Rhodes was a good man or a bad man, and instead reflect on other aspects of his legacy.

Many Rhodes Scholars went on to be Kings and Princes and Presidents of great countries. They are rich and famous and powerful. But I rather think that because he endowed education Rhodes would like to know that many more scholars went quietly into scholarship. There are many ways to be a leader, not all of which involve fame and fortune. It may even be that in the end the legacy of Empire which he wished to preserve will be defended not by the power-mongers who have all embraced the Woke and denounced him (while keeping his money, of course) but by those who came to believe in the ideals which underpin the scholarship and learning he funded: the ideals of reason, rationality, free speech and open debate. 

Perhaps Rhodes would also be amused to hear how I ended up in Cambridge rather than Oxford. Being a man of his time, he laboured under the shocking historical delusion that the Oxford experience is unique. You can't blame him for that. Long ago they thought differently about such things. He probably thought of Cambridge as nothing more than a less illustrious little brother (it's an ancient feud). In these enlightened times nobody holds Oxford in that sort of uncritical regard. The Equality Act tells us that all universities are now to be regarded as equal. But Rhodes would, I'm sure, agree that it's just as well because Oxford is now ashamed to be associated with him. A plaque has been installed to give 'context' to his statue at Oriel College. The plaque declaims in the immortal words of frightened cowards everywhere: It wasn't us, we never! 

Well, Mr Rhodes, your legacy has taken a very different path from that which you might have predicted. But then, being a great adventurer, you would be used to life's odd little twists and turns and I hope that the Wokie Tokies dancing around your statue will not trouble you unduly. I wonder if you knew that one day the vultures would come circling round the hilltop where you chose to lie buried.  Rest easy, Son of Africa. In the end, the only place a legacy can truly endure is in the hearts of those who embrace it.

1 Comment
Nikki link
14/10/2021 10:59:44 pm

I always look forward to your posts and this one is another brilliant read. Cecil Rhodes is a fascinating historical figure, so I was chuffed to discover you'd written about him! His story has been widely documented but there is still no end to the mystery of how one man's ambitions could affect the lives of generations of people years ahead. He was a man of colossal dreams and daring ambition far beyond human capacity. An Elon Musk of the Victorian era perhaps? Even as poor health troubled him all his life he still achieved more in one lifetime than ordinary people can do even in multiple lifetimes. He was an imperialist, explorer, politician, adventurer, farmer, mining magnate, businessman and dreamer rolled into one. He would have been interesting to debate with. Wanjiru, I think he would've enjoyed to have a deep conversation with you.

Dying aged only 48, his last journey through Africa in the funeral train to the Matopo Hills was a triumphal procession. I read that he often sat alone, up on the summit of Malindidzimu "Hill of the Spirits", where he is buried, to gather his thoughts. A "safe space" of sorts. Here he seemed to find true peace. I believe he truly felt that his heart and soul belonged in Africa, not in England. As much as he is derided and demonised today, Cecil is still making money for his former Rhodesia - his grave draws vast numbers of tourists and generates much-needed income for Zimbabwe's struggling economy. The grave is protected in terms of both the Rhodes Estates Act and the National Museums and Monuments Act. Tampering with it is a criminal offence.

Would Cecil have approved of large crowds of tourists ascending his beloved Malindidzimu to take selfies and gawp? I think not. But he would be delighted to know how many have benefitted from Rhodes Scholarships.

As he remarked about the hill at the time- “The peacefulness of it all: the chaotic grandeur of it: it creates a feeling of awe and brings home to one how very small we all are.”

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Wanjiru Njoya

    Scholar, Writer, Friend

    Archives

    May 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    July 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    January 2021
    July 2020
    April 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017

    Categories

    All
    Academic
    Capitalism
    Income Inequality
    Liberty
    Redistribution

    RSS Feed

Copyright © 2015
Photos used under Creative Commons from stefan.erschwendner, Sustainable Economies Law Center, erikaow, trendingtopics, Sustainable Economies Law Center, musee de l'horlogerie, Sustainable Economies Law Center, tracie7779, Michela Simoncini, cliff1066™, topten5, thedailyenglishshow, symphony of love, wuestenigel, uncafelitoalasonce, symphony of love, CarlH_
  • Home
  • Browse
  • About
  • Conversations